Law.com Home Newswire LawJobs CLE Center LawCatalog Our Sites Advertise
New York Lawyer Advertisement:
Click Here
A New York Law Journal publication

Home | Register | Login | Classified Ads | Message Boards

Search
Public Notices
New! Create a Domestic LLC/LLP Public Notice
Law Firms
NYLJ Professional
Announcements
The NYLJ 100
The AmLaw 100
The AmLaw 200
The AmLaw Midlevel
Associates Survey
The Summer
Associates Survey
The NLJ 250
Beyond Firms
The New York Bar Exam
Pro Bono
NYLJ Fiction Contest
Get Advice
Advice for the Lawlorn
Crossroads
Work/Life Wisdom
Message Boards
Services
Contact Us
Corrections
Make Us Your
Home Page
Shop LawCatalog.com
This Week's
Public Notices
Today's Classified Ads
Who We Are
 
 
Work/Life Wisdom

New York Lawyer
January 17, 2002

Q:
My firm is very dedicated to the idea of �family.� It�s been around for a long time, has a distinguished history, etc. I came in as a lateral partner recently and have been struck by how many incompetent staff people and attorneys are allowed to stay on, despite their obvious shortcomings. This �family� thing seems to make it impossible for folks to realize that they�re being taken advantage of.

I�ve made some noises about the appalling �help� I�ve been receiving � copies made on a very leisurely schedule, copies with missing pages, rampant misspellings, you name it � but as a relative newcomer, I�m a little reluctant to go on and on about this. How would you handle the situation?

Submit Your
Question
Find More
Answers
A:
Many, many organizations think of themselves as a family. It�s one of the most frequent metaphors used to describe a company or professional firm, and is usually said with pride: �We like to think of ourselves as family.� I can�t tell you how many organizations I�ve worked with or known about where this has been both a blessing and a curse.

The upside is obvious: a congenial, warm, supportive atmosphere, a place where people want to go every day, and a place where they maintain long-term ties. But the downside may outweigh the benefits: deadwood personnel, more work for everyone else, frustration at unclear standards for work and advancement, lack of pride and lowered morale. After all, you can�t fire your family. Nowadays many people prefer to think of their colleagues as a team, rather than family, emphasizing respect and trust among workers. It lessens the uncomfortable pressure of having to deal with non-performing �family members.�

As for dealing with this problem, you�re right that your newcomer status may discredit you, at least for the moment. However, it�s often outsiders who can see problems most clearly. Smart management takes advantage of new people to help them take an unvarnished look at what�s working and what isn�t in their organizations.

Therefore, this non-performance situation is a symptom of larger issues. Without a broad commitment to high performance, those lackadaisical employees will remain rooted in place. Rather than hitting partners head-on with the notion that they�re coddling incompetents � which will just make them defensive -- why not suggest that the firm commit or recommit to a broad vision for the future? If the management committee or partnership as a whole has wide-ranging conversations about where the firm is headed, fitting enhanced performance standards into such a vision will be much simpler than if they are isolated.

Another proven approach, if you would prefer to deal with firmwide attitudes about what �family� means, is to have discussions led by an outside facilitator where you talk through this issue. Often people will reveal that they don�t care for the family metaphor, because of the things you point out in your question, and want to move on to a vision that better requires accountability for everyone � not just the favored family members.

Sincerely,
Holly English
Principal Consultant, Values at Work


 




All Today's Classified Ads

ATTORNEY

ROCKEFELLER CENTER

lawjobs
Search For Jobs

Job Type

Region

Keyword (optional)


LobbySearch
Find a Lobbyist
Practice Area
State Ties


Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

  About ALM  |  About Law.com  |  Customer Support  |  Terms & Conditions