Page 44 - Verdicts and Settlements Hall of Fame: Medical Malpractice
P. 44





MEDICAL MALPRACTICE
VERDICT & SETTLEMENTS
HALL OF FAME




FAILURE TO COMMUNICATE

Category 

Rank
Case Date
Resolution
Award Total
Case Name
Case Type
Plaintif Law Firm


1
1/10/2014
Verdict- 62,000,000
Galette v. Byrne
Failure to Sanford A. Rubenstein, Brooklyn, 

Plaintif
Communicate
NY, of Rubenstein & Rynecki and 
Ira M. Newman of Sanocki, 

Newman & Turret, LLP

2
11/15/2013
Verdict- 24,813,260
Sence v. Failure to homas A. More, New York, NY, 
Plaintif
Atoynatan
Communicate
Kramer, Dillof, Livingston & 

Moore

3
10/9/2009
Verdict- 4,194,000
Leone v. Byrnes
Failure to homas P. Giufra, New York, NY 
Plaintif
Communicate
of Barton Barton & Plotkin, LLP

4
5/6/2011
Settlement
4,000,000
Perazzo v. Failure to Michael M. Bast, New York, NY of 

Maimonides Communicate
Silverstein & Bast
Medical Center

5
9/25/2013
Verdict- 3,609,000
Best v. Ryndin
Failure to Cliford S. Argintar, New York, NY 

Plaintif
Communicate
of Sullivan Papain Block McGrath 
& Cannavo P.C.

6
5/26/2009
Settlement
1,900,000
Sandler v. Kigel
Failure to Michael W. Gunzburg, New York, 

Communicate
NY of Michael Gunzburg, P.C.

6
5/26/2009
Settlement
1,900,000
Sandler v. Kigel
Failure to Joseph A. Ruta, New York, NY of 
Communicate
Ruta & Soulios LLP, trial counsel, 
Michael Gunzburg, P.C.

7
4/22/2013
Settlement
1,100,000
Schultz v. Failure to Nicholas A. Wise and Allan 

Queens-Long Communicate
Zelikovic, New York, NY of Weitz 
Isalnd Medical & Luxenberg P.C.

Group, P.C.





INFECTION CONTROL



Category 
Rank
Case Date
Resolution
Award Case Name
Case Type
Plaintif Law Firm

Total

1
3/4/2010
Settlement
7,400,000
Chapins v. Marmur
Infection Richard Gurfein, New York, NY 
Control
of Gurfein Douglas LLP

2
11/21/2011
Verdict- 3,250,000
Kremer v. Liefrig
Infection homas P. Giufra, New York, NY 

Plaintif
Control
of Rheingold, Valet & Rheingold, 
P.C.

3
8/4/2014
Verdict- 2,352,000
Antonucci v. Infection Evan M. Goldberg, New York, NY 
Mixed
Advanced Control
of Trolman, Glaser & Lichtman, 

Odrthopedics & P.C.
Sports Medicine, 

PLLC

4
3/6/2012
Settlement
2,000,000
Narvaez v. Stewart
Infection Eric K. Schwartz, New York, NY 
Control
of Sullivan Papain Block McGrath 

& Cannavo P.C.



42 November 2014



   42   43   44   45   46